Johanna Härling Christenson Part 2

It's been several months since I posted Johanna's personal history which was written by her daughter, Hannah. If it's been a while since you've read it, I would suggest going back and reading it (here) before you continue on.

It's hard to know how much input Johanna had in the writing of this history. Did she provide Hannah with the information? If so, was it done later in Johanna's life when details were no longer clear? Or was it written solely from Hannah's recollection of what she remembered her mother saying and stories Johanna told throughout her daughter's life? There's really no way to know for sure. But we can fact check a few things. I also think it's important try to dissect this narrative a little bit and attempt to better understand how many of the events in Johanna's life may have affected her.

"When Johanna was about 6 years of age, her mother died and her father married a widow. . ."

I not only fact-checked this with familysearch.org, I also went back and looked at the actual Swedish church records. Johanna's mother died just 20 days shy of Johanna's 9th birthday. It was 15 months later when her father, Johannes, married Britta Andersdotter and brought Maja Stina into the family. Johanna was 10 yrs. old, not 6, when her father remarried. Maja Stina was about 5 years younger than Johanna.

It's interesting to note, also, that although Maja Stina's last name was listed as Larsdotter, I can find no record of her mother, Britta, as ever having been married prior to marrying Johanna's father. Further, Britta gave birth to a son, Anders, 2 months before she married Johannes, leading me to think she had recently lost her first husband. However, the birth record clearly lists Johannes Härling (spelled the way it's pronounced - Herling) as the father. So, to clarify the timeline, Johanna's mother dies, 4 months later her father gets Britta pregnant, 9 months later Britta gives birth, and 2 months after that Johannes and Britta are wed. We really don't know exactly when Britta, Maja Stina, and the new baby actually moved in.

That would also make Johanna at least 10 years old (and Maja Stina at least 5 years old) when the haunted house incident occurred. They were more than likely older than that.


"Johanna's outstanding features were courage and perseverance. She was of a deeply religious nature."


I love knowing that about her. Since I have the benefit of knowing her future, those characteristics were important assets in facing the challenges which were placed in her path. Her relationship with God proved to get her and her children through some really tough times.


"When Johanna was fourteen years of age she went to live with her sister . . ."

I spent the better part of the day yesterday working on this one. I only got part of the information I was looking for. Johanna was 16 when she left her father's home in Herrljunga where she was born and raised. (Her father, by the way, was a career military man.) She went to Alingsås, about 35 miles away. She lived there for 3 years and then, when she was 19,  returned to Herrljunga. Even though she returned to her hometown, she did not return to the family home. A "Johanna Johannesdotter" moved from Herrljunga when my Johanna would have been 21, but, since the priest did not list birth dates, I can't say for certain it was her. I know all that from finding her on the Swedish "moving in and out" records (inflyttnings och utflyttningslängder); however, the parish priests failed to list her in the household records - or if they did, I was unable to find her. Because of that, I have no way of knowing if she lived with her sister the first time she left Herrljunga at the age of 16, if her sister lived in Herrljunga and Johanna returned and lived with her there, or if she went to live with with her at the age of 19. It could also be any combination of those options. Someday, I'll do some more digging. Wherever she was living when she was 23 would have been her last residence in Sweden before coming to "Amerika", and that place of residence I have no idea.


". . . she had to row in a row boat across the lake, which was two miles across . . ."

Currently, there are no lakes near Herrljunga. There are, however, many lakes near Alingsås. There is also a lake near Kvinnestad, 18 miles from Herrljunga, where, if I'm reading the priest's abbreviated chicken scratch correctly, she may have ended up. Obviously, I'm going to need more time to figure this all out.


"This lady kept a cafe at a railroad junction and she begged Johanna to come and work there . . ."


That had to feel good! What an enormous boost to her self-esteem and level of confidence!


"Johanna was broken hearted at leaving her sweetheart, and there was no way to send him word,  She felt it was her duty to go and help her sister."

Yeah. This is pretty heartbreaking when I really allow myself to think about it. She was young, independent, and in love. Her employer valued her and her beau loved her. She rushed off to the aid of her sister fully believing she would be back to the life she left behind. But it was not to be. "Duty" demanded something quite different - something that would change the course of her life in ways she never could have imagined.


"She was baptized, not knowing anything about Mormonism . . ."

The more stories and accounts I read, the more I understand that this was not uncommon. We are led to believe that most everyone who joined the church in foreign lands and immigrated to Utah were fully converted to the gospel. Actually, missionaries used all sorts of tactics to entice converts. Some people truly were converted and came primarily for religious reasons. Many were promised cheap land and endless opportunity - a huge enticement for poor, poverty-stricken migrant farmers who made up a large portion of early Mormon immigrants. Often, the favorable climate and clean air of the Salt Lake Valley was used to bring those with various health concerns into the fold. Sometimes, a husband was converted to the promise of his personal eternal kingdom and glory while the wife was duty-bound to follow obediently behind him. Others, I'm sure, were looking for opportunity and adventure.

It should also be noted that it was nearly impossible to immigrate to the US without a sponsor and a place to go. Future immigrants were completely dependent on former friends and relatives to guarantee them housing and support upon arriving at their final US destination - immigration laws demanded it. Because the church was able to guarantee sponsorship and support every step of the way, along with the popular Perpetual Immigration Fund (which ultimately gave high-interest loans to people who could not acquire necessary funding any other way) it created a simple, secure opportunity for the peasants and working-class to seek a better way of life. What enticed Johanna's sister, Christina, and her husband to join the church we'll never know for sure, but, given their urgency to immigrate, I believe one or more of the factors listed above had to have played at least a part in their decision.

Also, I find myself compelled to ask this question: As a single, unattached female, if Johanna knew about Mormon polygamy prior to leaving Sweden - and really understood its practice and implications - would she have still agreed to go?


"So the little boy died on the way to Nebraska. . . .  The little girl died on the plains and was also wrapped up in a sheet and buried on the way."

So, so sad. But dare I state the obvious? Johanna could have stayed in Sweden with her job and her boyfriend and the outcome more than likely would have been exactly the same. (Of course, I don't really know where that would leave me...)


"Mt. Pleasant, Sanpete County being the destination of Johanna's sister. . ."

Sanpete County was primarily settled by Swedish and Danish immigrants. (In fact, my husband's Danish immigrants settled in Manti, Ephraim, and Centerfield in Sanpete County, though we can find no documentation that his people ever personally knew or interacted with my people.)


". . . they went on and stopped at American Fork over night in the yard of a man by the name of Dan (?) Harrington. . . . Johanna was invited to remain and work in the Harrington family, which she did. " 

So, yeah. Without children to help care for, it could appear that Johanna became more of a burden to her sister than an asset. Or possibly, knowing they would virtually be "camping" for a while before they could get a log structure built and a residence established, and, realizing everything Johanna had sacrificed at their request, Christina and her husband may have been willing to let Johanna stay in American Fork if it meant her being able to live in a warm, comfortable home.

I couldn't find a "Dan" Harrington on familysearch who fit the story. I did find, however, Leonard E. Harrington, a native New Yorker and Mormon bishop, who lived in American Fork from 1850 until his death in 1883. More than likely, Leonard is the guy.  And this is probably the house Johanna lived in with his family:



When Johanna would have arrived in American Fork, Bishop Harrington would have had 4 wives and 11 children (according to familysearch.org). He would go on to marry another woman - 5 wives in all - and father of 16 or 17 children. I can't be sure exactly how many children he had as two of the children listed by different mothers on familysearch have exactly the same name and birth date. Obviously one is a duplicate, but there must be some confusion as to who the mother was.

Oh wait, a newspaper article attached to him on familysearch indicates that he only had 3 wives and 18 children. His two additional wives must have been sealed to him as "eternal wives" only - after the women had died. I don't see any reference to any other houses, so they must have all lived together in the residence pictured above. Leonard Harrington was not only a bishop, he was, at times, Justice of the Peace, a member of the House of Representatives for the Utah Territory, Mayor of American Fork, Postmaster, a Trustee of the Brigham Young Academy and Timpanogas University, a State Legislator, and President of the American Fork Mercantile Institution.

From familysearch, it looks like one of Leonard's living wives was a native New Yorker and the other two were English-born, so, for Johanna, only being able to speak Swedish would have been a real challenge. But, no doubt, it would have been in the Harrington home where Johanna would have learned the English language. (A little more commentary on the whole language thing later.)

So, let's review: Johanna was living her life in a beautiful area of southern Sweden surrounded by lakes and trees and flowers. It was a good life! Her employer advocated for her - begged for her - and her boyfriend loved her. She was very abruptly and unexpectedly taken out of her life, fully expecting to return, but, instead, felt duty-bound to be baptized into a high-demand religion which she knew absolutely nothing about to travel to a foreign country where she did not have the money nor means to return home should she ever desire to do so. The children she was recruited to help care for died along the way and were denied proper burials. Her sister - her only relative in this primitive, undeveloped US territory - left her with total strangers who lived an extremely unorthodox lifestyle - who spoke a completely different language - and moved on. As a young 23 yr. old woman who had never been more than 35 miles from the Swedish home in which she was born, can you even imagine the culture shock Johanna was experiencing?

How did she ever survive? Here is where we learn that Johanna was, indeed, in possession of much courage and perseverance as her daughter, Hannah, indicated. One would have to be an extraordinary individual to survive such an ordeal.

But again, here are my burning questions of the day: What did she really think about polygamy? What did she know before she left Sweden?

Did she have any idea it was a Mormon thing before arriving at the Harrington home? Had it even been discussed with her at all? Did her sister even know? Without any real grasp of the language and the culture, was she erroneously led to believe, at least initially, that polygamy was part of perfectly acceptable American culture? If so, when did that all change? And how long did she struggle with the concept of plural marriage, if at all, before finally giving in? So many questions . . .


UPDATE: A little more digging in familysearch and the Swedish records and I was able to piece together a few more pieces of the puzzle. Per the Swedish "moving in" records, Johanna did go to Alingsås when she was 16 yrs. old - in October 1856. Also in 1856, I found her moving in with her sister, Christina, in Hemsjö.




The map tells us that Alingsås is about 30 miles from Herrljunga and it's on the way to Hemsjö which is only about 9 miles further down the road. The "moving in" record listed many, many young single adults checking in with the priest in Alingsås on the same day as Johanna. I'm thinking maybe she traveled with a group of friends or acquaintances going as far as Alingsås and got caught up in the line of people checking in with the priest who were staying there even though she was only spending one night on her way to her sister's house in Hemsjö. Since it was her first time away from home on her own, that's perfectly understandable.

Per the household index (below) Christina and her husband, Pehr, moved to Hemsjö from Lundby in 1855. Johanna (crossed out at the bottom of the record) joined them from Herrljunga in 1856 and returned to Herrljunga in 1859.


Household Index, Hemsjö, 1849-1860

What this tells me is that the store owned by Christina in which Johanna worked and helped out was in Hemsjö. I re-read what Hannah wrote, that Johanna "had to row in a row boat across the lake, which was two miles across, to get supplies for the store.  She was always a lover of beauty and so she loved this part of her work very much because the lake was so beautiful.  Flowers and shrubs all around it and on the other side was a forest with beautiful trees, flowers, grass and all kinds of fruit and berries she could pick."  I had to find a few modern-day photos to better imagine where Johanna lived and worked. And, by the way, Hemsjö is completely surrounded by lakes.





















It was probably in 1859 when Johanna left Hemsjö to work for the lady who had the cafe in the train station. I can't say for sure the cafe was in Herrlunga as the record (above) is Johanna's dead end - that's the last Swedish record I can find with her name on it. I've searched all the Herrljunga records at least twice and can't find anything that confirms she moved back there. That doesn't mean she didn't - that just means she either didn't notify the priest in Herrljunga that she was back or he never wrote it down. There's also a good chance she went somewhere else and the priest in Hemsjö was mistaken.


I do know Christina and family stayed in Hemsjö up until the time they left for Utah because of this:

Household Index, Hemsjö, 1861-1877

You can see that the priest who kept the record identified them as "Mormoner" and they left for "Norra Amerika" 10 April 1863.

So, a couple of things. Hannah's history of Johanna implied that Christina and family joined the church and left for Utah very soon after they were baptized. Familysearch shows Pehr's baptism date to be 1 January 1862, 16 months before they left Sweden. I don't think their membership in the Mormon church was a last minute surprise to Johanna as there was more than enough time to spread the word. Johanna, however, was baptized 11 April 1863, 7 days after Pehr, Christina, and family left Hemsjö. Johanna's baptism was definitely last minute. I'm not sure where they would have met up with missionaries who would accompany the group of immigrants to Zion - probably Goteborg - but that's more than likely when and where Johanna's baptism happened.

I was under the impression Pehr and Christina only had 2 children and lost both of them during the land-travel portion of their trip. But it's very clear from the Swedish records as well as the ship's passenger list (below)  - and familysearch - that they had an older daughter, "Anna" Christina, who made it to Utah with them. Daughter, Johanna Maria, and son, Johan Alfred, were the children who died en route. They also had another daughter, Augusta, who had died as an infant prior to ever leaving Sweden.




It's also important to understand that they came with a huge group of Mormon immigrants - around 700 people (see voyage accounts here) - and the vast majority of them were Scandinavian. I don't know how long they were in Salt Lake City before being assigned a place to settle. But since Swedes and Danes were being sent to Sanpete County, it was probably a large group of Saints who converged on Bishop Harrington's house in American Fork to spend the night in the yard. That makes the fact that Bishop Harrington singled out Johanna and offered her employment in his home quite compelling. Available, single women in their early 20's were hard to come by as Mormon men were routinely taking teenage girls as plural wives. With only 3 living wives at the time, maybe the good, faithful bishop had sights on her himself.

Comments